Your skin tone/coloring: Light medium complexion with warm yellow undertones, dark brown hair and eyes
Best black eyeliner? Physicians Formula Eye Booster Waterproof Ultra-Fine Liquid Eyeliner will always be the best I ever tried, great formula, great pigmentation, easy to use by eyeliner noobs like me, great staying power (my runny eyes and oily kids are a bad combo).
There are some expensive options that work just as well for me, like KVD Tattoo Liner or Fenti Flyliner, but Physicians Formula wins with the price
Gel, liquid, or pencil eyeliner? I would say a liquid with gel vibes; I use pencils usually to tightline and liquid eyeliners for winged looks, for me they are not an interchangeable product.
Most dramatic mascara? I actually dislike too dramatic mascaras that add tons of volume and make lashes look really big; I like my lashes jet black, defined, separated, still somewhat soft. I feel like dramatic lashes impair my vision. So I don’t have a positive experience with dramatic mascaras.
The ones that “scared” me enough to be remembered (yes, I hate that much having tons of volume on my lashes; and yes, false lashes will never touch me) are some of the Maybelline Colossal mascaras (they also have the worse eyeliner ever, to the previous questions) and Lancome Monsieur Big.